|
“Few compositions
are as genuinely melancholy as ‘You
Don’t What Love Is.’” |
|
 |
|
- JW
|
|
|
|
Remarkably, “You Don’t Know What
Love Is” and “I’ll
Remember April,” two of the
top jazz standards, were both written
for Bud Abbott and Lou Costello films by
Gene De Paul and Don Raye and published
in 1941. Actress
Carol Bruce sang “You
Don’t Know What Love Is”
for the
1941 Universal film, Keep
‘Em Flying, which
also starred
Dick Foran and Martha Raye.
“I’ll
Remember April” was introduced
by
Dick Foran in Ride ‘Em Cowboy
(1942).
“You Don’t Know What Love Is”
was dropped from Keep
‘Em Flying before
it was released but performed by
Bruce a short time later in the
1942 film Behind the Eight
Ball.
|
| |
|
After success on radio and Broadway,
Abbott and Costello took their brand
of slapstick comedy to film, beginning
with One Night in the Tropics
(1940) and ending over thirty films
later with Dance with Me Henry
(1956). Don Raye teamed with Hugh
Prince for the score of the comedy
duo’s second film, Buck Privates
(1941), in which the Andrews Sisters
introduced the upcoming hit, “Boogie
Woogie Bugle Boy.” The film was
a box office success, grossing over
ten million dollars.
Anxious to repeat the formula,
top-name vocalists were worked into
successive plots; the Andrews Sisters
returned for Abbott and Costello’s
third and fourth films,
In the Navy (1941) and Hold that
Ghost (1941), and Ella Fitzgerald
was given a bit part as a maid,
singing “A
Tisket, A Tasket” in their sixth
film, Ride ‘Em Cowboy (1942).
Universal would also repeat their
success with lyricist Raye, pairing
him with composer Gene De Paul for
In the Navy and Keep
‘Em Flying in 1941 and Ride ‘Em Cowboy in 1942.
|
| |
|
|
| |
|
A broad farce, Keep
‘Em Flying
casts the boys as carnival workers
who follow a stunt pilot into the
Army Air Corps.
Carol Bruce portrays a USO singer
and Martha Raye plays identical
twins. Songs in the score include,
“Let’s Keep ‘Em Flying,” “Pig Foot
Pete,” and “The Boy With the Wistful
Eyes.”
Few compositions are as genuinely
melancholy as “You Don’t What Love
Is.” As such, it is difficult to
find the title mentioned without
an accompanying characterization
including, “strange,” “intense,”
“gloomy,” “smoky,” “late night,”
“sad,” “passionate,” and, of course,
“haunting.” Don Raye’s piercing
lyrics accentuate the heartbreaking
feeling staged by De Paul. You don’t
know what love is, he claims, until
you’ve learned the meaning of the
blues. As one critic puts it, “the
lyrics draw out the exquisite pain!”
The song was never a major hit,
but was recorded occasionally in
the ‘40s, and then brought into
the jazz canon in the 1950’s when
it was recorded by Miles Davis and
others.
|
|
|
|
Musical analysis of
“You Don't Know What Love Is”
|
| Original
Key |
G minor |
| Form |
A1 – A2 –
B – A2 |
| Tonality |
Primarily
minor |
| Movement |
Leaps (6th
– 7th) and skips (3rd), followed by scale
runs up and down in both directions |
|
Comments
(assumed
background)
|
|
This is the perfect title music for a film-noir,
similar in character to “Harlem
Nocturne.” The chord progression starts
out i – Ger+6 – V7 (Gm – Eb7 – D7, in which
the second chord is really decorative rather
than functional). Melody notes falling on
color tones or chord extensions such as
the 9th, b9, #5, b5, 13, etc. are common.
These notes create harmonic tension and
give the song a tortured ambiance as befits
the lyrics. (NOTE on “Ger+6” or “German
augmented sixth” chord: this is the theorist’s
label for a bVI7 chord that normally resolves
toV7, i.e. C – Ab7 – G7. In popular music
of the 1920-1950’s era, the chord is used
more decoratively and rarely resolves to
the V7.) |
K. J. McElrath - Musicologist for JazzStandards.com
Check out K. J. McElrath's book of Jazz Standards Guide Tone Lines at his web site (www.bardicle.com). |
|
|
I never tire of “You Don’t Know What Love Is.”
It has wonderful harmonic movement and intervals
and a really great bridge. You can solo on it, double-time
it, and it still keeps its ballad character. It’s
a favorite of vocalists and instrumentalists.
Jay
Clayton, jazz vocalist
www.jayclayton.com
Are you a
published Vocalist or Instrumentalist?
Add a comment and we'll credit you with a link
to your site. (more...)
|
“You Don't Know What Love
Is” was included in these films:
- Keep 'Em Flying (1941, Carol
Bruce, dropped before release)
- Behind the Eight Ball aka Off the
Beaten Track (1942, Carol Bruce with Sonny Durham
and His Orchestra)
- Love at Large (1990)
- This World, Then the Fireworks
(1997, Chet Baker)
- Anywhere But Here (1999)
- The Talented Mr. Ripley (1999,
1-Jude Law dubbed by Alan Barnes, 2-John Martyn,
The Guy Barker International Quintet)
|
|
Click on a CD for more details
at Amazon.com
Fred Hersch/Jay Clayton
Beautiful Love
1995, Sunnyside 1066
|
| Vocalist Clayton moves in both jazz
and new music circles, and here she colors
her first CD of all standards with the distinctive
palette she has developed over years of
creating her own music. The duo setting
with pianist Hersch highlights the talents
of both. |
Sonny Rollins
Saxophone Colossus
1991, Orig. Jazz Classics 291
Original recording, 1956
|
| Saxophonist Rollins does the slow
burn on this fantastic instrumental version
of the song. His rich horn fills all the
corners with its forlorn sound. |
Jesus ‘Chucho’ Valdes
New Conceptions
2003 Blue Note
|
| Pianist Valdes swings the song with
plenty of flourishes and a Latin rhythm.
While the mood is lightened considerably,
the piano playing is deadly serious. |
Leon Parker
Above and Below
1994, Sony 66144
|
| Drummer Parker uses one cymbal and
one drum, lending primitive overtones to
the song in this haunting, meditative rendition.
Ugonna Okegwo anchors on bass while David
Sanchez’s soprano sax floats gently on top. |
Lenny Tristano
Lenny Tristano/The New Lenny Tristano
1994, Rhino 71595
Original recording, 1962, Atlantic
|
| Tristano has served as guru to many
musicians. This CD combines two accessible
LP’s featuring him solo and in two trio
settings, with altoist Lee Konitz occasionally
making it four. “You Don’t Know What Love
Is” is a thought provoking piano solo. |
|
|
Recordings from 1941 of this tune are all from
big bands with male vocalists: Dick Haymes with
Harry James, Art Lund with
Benny Goodman, and Billy Eckstine with Earl
Hines.
Ten years would pass until guitarist Jimmy Raney
would record a classic, non-vocal version. Then
the tune would become the property of several great
trumpet players. Two versions are from 1952: Miles
Davis recorded an instrumental rendition while Chet
Baker (who has been referred to as a Davis sound-alike
on the trumpet) would do a soulful, vocal version
Trumpeter Thad Jones, a member of Count Basie’s
band in 1954, would get a chance to lead his own
quartet with an instrumental version of the tune,
while in 1956 his brother, pianist Hank Jones, would
record it on his own session.
Chris Tyle - Jazz Musician and Historian
Hank Jones
Have You Met Hank Jones?
Savoy MG 12084 (LP record, out-of-print)
|
|
This section shows the jazz standards
written by the same writing team. Click on a name
to see all of a writer's jazz standards.
|
|
Additional information on “You Don't Know What Love Is” may be found in:
1 paragraph including the following types of information: summary and performers.
1 paragraph including the following types of information: film productions, history, lyric analysis, music analysis and performers.
Includes the following types of information: song lyrics.
|
|